Skip to content
646 269 0773|alita@globalbioethics.org
facebooktwitterlinkedin
Global Bioethics Initiative (GBI) Logo Global Bioethics Initiative (GBI) Logo Global Bioethics Initiative (GBI) Logo
  • Home
  • About
  • Staff
    • Founders
    • Board of Directors
    • Advisory Board
    • Visiting Scholars
    • Student Interns
    • Volunteers
  • Events
  • Resources
    • COVID-19
  • Internships
  • Contact
  • Donate
Previous Next
  • View Larger Image Kris Chung has become part of Binh and Phuoc Wagner’s lives after he donated part of his liver to Binh. Phuoc got her adopted dad’s liver.

Organs for the rich and cute: Should patients campaign for their own donors?

By Ada Roberts

This week the Canadian Society of Transplantation released a report officially sanctioning the practice of publicly campaigning for organ donors, a practice that made headlines last year when two Canadian parents were desperately searching for functional kidneys for their recently adopted twins. The practice, says the report, is “ethically and legally acceptable” because it does not hurt anyone and the potential concerns of such a practice are outweighed by its benefits – namely, raising awareness for “organ donorship in general”, says Dr. Atul Hamar, the Transplantation Society’s president.

Public campaigns for organ donations have recently started utilizing social media platforms, such as Facebook and Twitter, as tools to make their pleas truly public. Ottawa Senators owner Eugene Melnyk, for instance, received a new liver last year following an online post about his need for a donor. These direct donations, the ones that follow from public solicitation, are not immune to criticism. Critics claim the practice of publicly  is unethical and problematic because, ultimately, it is unfair. Some may not have the resources or savvy to launch a social media campaign for their cause, and others, that is, most people, don’t own sports teams.

Daniel Buchman, a bioethicist at the University Health Network in Toronto, does not see the practice as inherently problematic. Rather, because inequities are already built into society, such as those that arise when someone in need of a donor has a larger family or network from which to search for a donor than someone with a comparatively smaller family, the practice itself is not unethical.

In an ideal world, there would be so many registered organ donors that public pleas and extensive donor waiting lists would not be necessary. Until then, though, the debate will likely rage on.

Read more: here; https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2016/10/23/organs-for-the-rich-and-cute-should-patients-campaign-for-their-own-donors.html

Other Posts

Around 30%’ of eligible NY medical workers refusing COVID-19 vaccine: officialMalvika2021-01-10T13:28:50+00:00
Study suggests Pfizer vaccine works against virus variantMalvika2021-01-10T13:19:53+00:00
Rich Countries Have ‘Bought Up’ COVID-19 Vaccine Supply, Art Caplan SaysMalvika2020-12-18T13:39:02+00:00
First shipments of Pfizer vaccine to be delivered December 15Malvika2020-12-03T16:15:19+00:00
By Ana Lita|2020-04-09T23:45:34+00:00October 28th, 2016|News-Articles|0 Comments

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

facebooktwitterlinkedinreddittumblrpinterestvkEmail

About the Author: Ana Lita

Ana Lita

Related Posts

  • Around 30%’ of eligible NY medical workers refusing COVID-19 vaccine: official
    Around 30%’ of eligible NY medical workers refusing COVID-19 vaccine: official
    Gallery

    Around 30%’ of eligible NY medical workers refusing COVID-19 vaccine: official

  • Study suggests Pfizer vaccine works against virus variant
    Study suggests Pfizer vaccine works against virus variant
    Gallery

    Study suggests Pfizer vaccine works against virus variant

  • Rich Countries Have ‘Bought Up’ COVID-19 Vaccine Supply, Art Caplan Says
    Rich Countries Have ‘Bought Up’ COVID-19 Vaccine Supply, Art Caplan Says
    Gallery

    Rich Countries Have ‘Bought Up’ COVID-19 Vaccine Supply, Art Caplan Says

  • First shipments of Pfizer vaccine to be delivered December 15
    First shipments of Pfizer vaccine to be delivered December 15
    Gallery

    First shipments of Pfizer vaccine to be delivered December 15

  • Bioethicists worry the rich and powerful will get special access to experimental Covid treatments
    Bioethicists worry the rich and powerful will get special access to experimental Covid treatments
    Gallery

    Bioethicists worry the rich and powerful will get special access to experimental Covid treatments

Leave A Comment Cancel reply

Recent Tweets

Tweets by GBISummerSchool

Find us on Facebook

Copyright 2012 - 2020 Global Bioethics | All Rights Reserved | Powered by Global Innovation Consortium
facebooktwitterlinkedin
Toggle Sliding Bar Area