Skip to content
646 269 0773|alita@globalbioethics.org
facebooktwitterlinkedin
Global Bioethics Initiative (GBI) Logo Global Bioethics Initiative (GBI) Logo Global Bioethics Initiative (GBI) Logo
  • Home
  • About
  • Staff
    • Founders
    • Board of Directors
    • Advisory Board
    • Visiting Scholars
    • Student Interns
    • Volunteers
  • Events
  • Resources
    • COVID-19
  • Internships
  • Contact
  • Donate
Previous Next
  • View Larger Image gavel

Russian Courts Ruled to Uphold Presumed Consent in Organ Donations

By Maria Coluccio

Last month, the Russian Constitutional Court published a ruling that upheld the legality of harvesting organs from a cadaver without the family’s permission. The ruling was a response to a lawsuit over the harvesting of a deceased Moscow student’s organs without the family’s consent. Alina Sablina was killed in a car accident in January 2014, and her parents were shocked to discover that several of her organs had been removed by a medical institution without their expressed permission. Her mother filed the lawsuit seeking compensation from the Russian medical institution. The official website of the Constitutional Court reported, “Russian medical institutions have the legal right to harvest organs from the deceased without notifying relatives”. This ruling is in line with the Article 8 of the 1992 federal law on the transplantation of organs and/or tissues of human beings, establishing a presumption of consent for the removal of organs for transplants. Presumed consent, also known as the ‘opt out system’, means that one’s organs can be used unless the deceased, or their family, registers an objection prior to the death.

There are both advantages and disadvantages to the opt out system for organ donations.
On one hand, presumed consent increases the supply of organs and can arguably make the donation process easier.  These advantages are attempts to solve the critical problem of organ shortages. It also removes the difficult decision the donor’s family face when asked for consent during a painful time.   On the other hand, there are ethical arguments against presumed consent. There are risks of registering one’s objection. An individual may not know that he or she has to object to consent, or if an objection notice was correctly received or processed. If either of these situations occurs, a person ‘presumed’ to have consented actually objected to the donation. Ethically, some argue that the opt out systems do not respect an individual’s right not to choose.

Solving the problem of organ shortages while still valuing an individual’s autonomy and right to choose is a complicated task that has both legal and ethical implications.

Read the full article here.

Other Posts

Invasion of Ukraine: Neighbours struggle with refugee influx; UN expresses ‘horror’ at Mariupol hospital attackAdmin2022-03-14T17:27:03+00:00
Russian doctors plead for end to warAdmin2022-03-14T04:17:28+00:00
Do not assume COVID pandemic reaching ‘end game’, warns WHOAdmin2022-01-24T23:56:31+00:00
Penangite Cheah Phaik YeongAdmin2022-01-24T23:36:02+00:00
By Admin@gbi|2020-04-09T23:48:19+00:00April 27th, 2016|News-Articles|0 Comments

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

facebooktwitterlinkedinreddittumblrpinterestvkEmail

About the Author: Admin@gbi

Avatar

Related Posts

  • Call for Applications! Bioethics of AI: The Intersection of AI and Medicine” Online Winter School December 16-21, 2024
    Call for Applications! Bioethics of AI: The Intersection of AI and Medicine” Online Winter School December 16-21, 2024
    Gallery

    Call for Applications! Bioethics of AI: The Intersection of AI and Medicine” Online Winter School December 16-21, 2024

  • AI Ethics: Why it matters! by Adarsh Srivastava, PGDISAD, Head of Data & Analytics Quality Assurance at Roche Diagnostics
    AI Ethics: Why it matters! by Adarsh Srivastava, PGDISAD, Head of Data & Analytics Quality Assurance at Roche Diagnostics
    Gallery

    AI Ethics: Why it matters! by Adarsh Srivastava, PGDISAD, Head of Data & Analytics Quality Assurance at Roche Diagnostics

  • A Unique, Eye-opening experience: A physician’s perspective by Rola Itani, MD
    A Unique, Eye-opening experience: A physician’s perspective by Rola Itani, MD
    Gallery

    A Unique, Eye-opening experience: A physician’s perspective by Rola Itani, MD

  • Jonathan D. Moreno Ph.D. Keynote Speaker
    Jonathan D. Moreno Ph.D. Keynote Speaker
    Gallery

    Jonathan D. Moreno Ph.D. Keynote Speaker

  • Jeanne F. Loring Ph.D. Keynote Speaker
    Jeanne F. Loring Ph.D. Keynote Speaker
    Gallery

    Jeanne F. Loring Ph.D. Keynote Speaker

Recent Tweets

Tweets by GBISummerSchool

Find us on Facebook

Copyright 2012 - 2020 Global Bioethics | All Rights Reserved | Powered by Global Innovation Consortium
facebooktwitterlinkedin
Toggle Sliding Bar Area