Legislation has recently come into effect in France that now presumes consent to organ donation. France’s previous policy required doctors to consult relatives in cases where deceased individuals had no clear directives regarding organ donation, and relatives refused in almost one third of the cases. The new policy means that all citizens will be organ donors unless they sign up on a ‘refusal register’. This legislation comes in the wake of persistent organ shortages and ever-growing transplant waiting lists. The hope is that an opt-out program will help alleviate this problem. The idea is to capitalize on human being’s ‘laziness’ of choosing the default option.

Some have suggested that the opt-out system will increase donation rates through reducing next-of-kin vetoes, while others have claimed that more people will donate because it will now be the status quo. In the U.S., where an opt-in system is used, the rate of organ donation is approximately 26.6 per 1 million people. This figure is considerably less than in Spain, which has a presumed consent system, and the rate of organ donation is about 35.7 per 1 million people.

However, the comparison of other presumed consent statistics indicate a more complex story: in Portugal and Belgium, for instance (both presumed consent countries) the organ donation rate is 27.3 and 26.9, respectively. This indicates the issue is more dependent on the context and culture of the individual countries in which it is applied. While not a cure-all, the opt-in system may make it easier to approach the issue with family members of donors.

Read more here and here

Other Posts

by Jonathan D. Moreno, Ph.D., Global Bioethics Initiative, Advisory Board Member David and Lyn Silfen University Professor , University of Pennsylvania Little noticed in the United States but a big deal in France, President Emmanuel Macron announced [...]

NYU surgeons hope a 3-D printed reproduction will encourage people to donate the faces of dying family members for use as transplants. By ANDY NEWMAN and MARC SANTORA JAN. 5, 2018 Most medical advances benefit the living. This one [...]

Michael S. Dauber, MA, GBI Visiting Scholar   On November 17th, Sergio Canavero announced what he claims to be the first successful test of head transplantation in a human cadaver. Canavero gained international attention in [...]

By Michael S. Dauber, GBI Visiting Scholar A recent article in New Republic highlights one of the hallmark areas of ethical controversy in bioethics: designing the fairest possible system for organ transplantation. The article, written [...]